Software & Technology

Digital Giving Platforms Compared: What Works Best

Michael Chen
·May 8, 2026·
6 min read
Digital Giving Platforms Compared: What Works Best

Online giving now accounts for 30-40% of total church giving. Choosing the right platform matters.

Tithe.ly

Fees: 2.9% + $0.30 per transaction Best for: Small to mid-size churches wanting an all-in-one solution Standout: Free church app included

Pushpay

Fees: Custom pricing (typically higher) Best for: Large churches prioritizing donor engagement Standout: Best-in-class mobile giving experience

Planning Center Giving

Fees: 2.9% + $0.30 Best for: Churches already using Planning Center Standout: Seamless integration with other PC modules

Stripe + Custom Integration

Fees: 2.9% + $0.30 Best for: Tech-savvy churches wanting full control Standout: Maximum flexibility

Our Verdict

Tithe.ly offers the best value for most churches. Pushpay is worth the premium for large churches focused on recurring giving.